How Scotland Reduced Violent Crime | John Carnochan

1h 19m · Defiance · 13 Feb 13:28

“I don’t mind these fellas being in gangs, it’s what the gangs do that is the issue for me. If the gangs are playing football or rugby that’s fine. If they are playing chess, if they are crocheting I really don’t care. It’s when they are out on a Friday night stabbing each other, that becomes an issue for me.”
— John Carnochan

Location: Glasgow
Date: Tuesday, 22nd January 2020
Company: Scottish Violence Reduction Unit
Role: Former Detective Chief Superintendent

When John Carnochan joined Strathclyde Police as deputy head of CID in 2002, Glasgow, in particular, was experiencing extreme levels of violent crime. Scotland had become the murder capital of Europe and had five times the murder rate of London.

The methods used by the police were mostly ineffective, so John took a radical approach, launching the Violence Reduction Unit (VRU) and the Community Initiative to Reduce Violence. This initiative offered education, health services, careers advice, social services and diversionary projects to the most vulnerable gang members.

The VRU was a massive success. In 2004/05 there were 137 homicides in Scotland. By 2016/17 this number had dropped to 62, attempted murders dropped from 828 to 317, and serious assaults fell by almost half.

In this interview, I talk to John Carnochan, former Detective Chief Superintendent. His Violence Reduction Unit and Community Initiative to Reduce Violence program helped significantly reduce violent crime and homicide rates in Scotland

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription: https://www.defiance.news/podcast/how-scotland-reduced-violent-crime-john-carnochan

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

The success of Defiance will be largely down to the support of you, the listener. Below are a number of ways you can help:
- Subscribe to the show on your favourite app so you never miss an episode:
iTunes
Spotify
Deezer
Stitcher
SoundCloud
YouTube
TuneIn
- Leave a review of the show on iTunes (5* really helps, if you think the show deserves it).
- Share the show and episodes out with your friends and family on Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn.
- Follow Defiance on social media:
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
- Subscribe to the Defiance mailing list.
- Donate Bitcoin here: bc1qd3anlc8lh0cl9ulqah03dmg3r2uxm5r657zr5p

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

The episode How Scotland Reduced Violent Crime | John Carnochan from the podcast Defiance has a duration of 1:19:58. It was first published 13 Feb 13:28. The cover art and the content belong to their respective owners.

Permalink

More episodes from Defiance

The Killing of Marie Colvin

In February 2012 - a year after the war in Syria had started - photographer Paul Conroy and Sunday Times correspondent Marie Colvin smuggled themselves into the war-ravaged Syrian city of Homs. As the first journalists on the scene, they witnessed the targeted attacks perpetrated by the Syrian government on women, children and civilian hospitals.

As they were broadcasting the siege of Homs live to the world, the Syrian regime was using their satellites to locate and target them. The missile attack that followed killed both Marie and French photojournalist Rémi Ochlik and severely injured Paul.

Ten years on since the start of the conflict in Syria, Paul Conroy talks to former Sunday Times journalist and colleague of Marie Colvin, Tom Pattinson, about those fateful hours in Homs.

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription:
DEF086 - Show Notes

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

The Digital Afterlife - DEF:Tech #002

If you could cheat death, would you?

Technology has progressed at a phenomenal rate, allowing us to do things deemed impossible. In this episode, Edwina Stott takes a look at the tech, which could enable us to live forever and asks whether an eternal digital afterlife is something we really want.

She speaks with Eugenia Kuyda, founder of Replika, who built a chatbot from her dead friend’s text messages; Professor Michael Graziano, who firmly believes that one day we’ll all upload our brains to a digital universe and Associate Professor Patrick Stokes, who explains why we’ll all have a digital afterlife - whether we like it, or not.

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription:
DEF:Tech #002 - Show Notes

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

Everyone Loves Britney - IV. Blackout

In Everyone Loves Britney, we investigate the complex conservatorship case of Britney Spears.

The series looks at her troubled past and what led to her being put under a conservatorship. We question the legality of the processes that took place, and analyse the problems within the probate court system. We speak to people who have been through conservatorships and the attorneys who want to see change. And we ask who stands to benefit from Britney's ongoing conservatorship that has cost her millions.

Does Britney really need the conservatorship, or is she being held against her will?

IV. Blackout
Britney's father has controlled her conservatorship for 13 years, but Britney has now said she will no longer perform whilst he is in control. In this episode, we look at who has been making money from Britney's estate and whether Britney really needs the conservatorship or not.

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription:
DEF085 - Show Notes

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

Everyone Loves Britney - III. Toxic

In Everyone Loves Britney, we investigate the complex conservatorship case of Britney Spears.

The series looks at her troubled past and what led to her being put under a conservatorship. We question the legality of the processes that took place, and analyse the problems within the probate court system. We speak to people who have been through conservatorships and the attorneys who want to see change. And we ask who stands to benefit from Britney's ongoing conservatorship that has cost her millions.

Does Britney really need the conservatorship or is she being held against her will?

III. Toxic
Britney’s previously absent father takes control of her life and wealth as her conservator but questions are asked as to whether she needs or wants a conservatorship. In this episode, we look at a system that has failed many of the most vulnerable it is meant to protect and what is being done to change the system.

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription:
DEF083 - Show Notes

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

Everyone Loves Britney - II. Circus

In Everyone Loves Britney, we investigate the complex conservatorship case of Britney Spears.

The series looks at her troubled past and what led to her being put under a conservatorship. We question the legality of the processes that took place, and analyse the problems within the probate court system. We speak to people who have been through conservatorships and the attorneys who want to see change. And we ask who stands to benefit from Britney's ongoing conservatorship that has cost her millions.

Does Britney really need the conservatorship or is she being held against her will?

II. Circus
At the height of her fame, Britney's struggles become apparent as the media frenzy around her starts to become dangerously intrusive and chronicles every aspect of her personal life. The collapse of her marriage and losing custody of her kids send her spiralling out of control and the public become judge and jury in a case that sees her locked into a court-appointed conservatorship.

- - - - -

Show notes and transcription:
DEF083 - Show Notes

- - - - -

Timestamps:
Coming soon…

- - - - -

If you have any questions then please email Defiance.

- - - - -

Every Podcast » Defiance » How Scotland Reduced Violent Crime | John Carnochan